Search This Blog

Sunday, July 21, 2013

BOXING: Malik Scott gets counted out, even though the referee didn’t appear to reach the count of 10




Malik Scott was counted out even though he appeared to get up at nine (Getty Images)


Malik Scott is probably never going to win the heavyweight championship, so in the grand scheme of things, Saturday's loss at Wembley Arena in London to Dereck "Del Boy" Chisora won't make much of a difference.

But fair is fair and referee Phil Edwards appeared to cost Scott a chance to win the fight and keep his unbeaten record.


Scott appeared to be clear-headed, as the announcers noted while examining the replay, and he took the count on one knee. In professional boxing, there is a mandatory eight-count after a knockout and a lot of fighters choose to take it on the knee as a way to clear their heads and catch a break.

Scott was clearly watching Edwards as the referee counted directly in front of him. Scott appears to get to his feet when Edwards reached nine. Inexplicably, though, Loughlin waved the bout off and called it a TKO for Chisora.

The countdown begins at the 23:40 mark and the announcers begin to break down the finish at about the 25-minute mark on the video. Edwards is counting and using his fingers as he administered the count. But he never said 10 or put up 10 fingers.

Malik Scott is probably never going to win the heavyweight championship, so in the grand scheme of things, Saturday's loss at Wembley Arena in London to Dereck "Del Boy" Chisora won't make much of a difference.

But fair is fair and referee Phil Edwards appeared to cost Scott a chance to win the fight and keep his unbeaten record.


Scott appeared to be clear-headed, as the announcers noted while examining the replay, and he took the count on one knee. In professional boxing, there is a mandatory eight-count after a knockout and a lot of fighters choose to take it on the knee as a way to clear their heads and catch a break.

Scott was clearly watching Edwards as the referee counted directly in front of him. Scott appears to get to his feet when Edwards reached nine. Inexplicably, though, Loughlin waved the bout off and called it a TKO for Chisora.

The countdown begins at the 23:40 mark and the announcers begin to break down the finish at about the 25-minute mark on the video. Edwards is counting and using his fingers as he administered the count. But he never said 10 or put up 10 fingers.

Source: http://sports.yahoo.com/blogs/boxing/

No comments: