Search This Blog

Thursday, January 16, 2014

Imagining the future of music




To appreciate music, we need to sing and play and compose more of it, says Andrew Ford






I
SUPPOSE all parents see the future in terms of their children. In pondering the future of music, then, as I was recently asked to do by the Music, Mind and Health conference at Melbourne University, my hopes centred on my three-year-old daughter.

Of course hopes always come with obstacles, and very often obstacles are pecuniary. Unless you’re singing – or playing homemade instruments – music will cost money and someone must pay. Australian governments have always supported the arts, not least because there’s copious evidence the subsidies bring in far more money than they cost. You’d have to be crazy or extremely ideological (which is possibly the same thing) to cut funding that generates wealth.

But some governments get in the way, because they want to fiddle and social engineer. You’ve read the platitudes. Music is a universal language. Through music we communicate feelings and tell our own stories. Music should be accessible, always relevant, never elitist. What depressing clichés!

In fact music is neither a language nor is it universal. If it were a language, you could translate it; if it were universal, we would all appreciate all music equally. And music doesn’t communicate feelings – it communicates music. We might feel emotional when we hear it – I frequently do – but that’s a personal response.

How can music be inaccessible? I have no idea. Some of it might take longer to appreciate; some of it might take a lifetime. But on the subject of paying for art, I’d say music that takes a lifetime to appreciate is giving excellent value for money. As for relevance: good music is always relevant, bad music is never relevant.

“Elitism” is simply the great Australian fear that other people might think they’re better than us. It’s that chip-on-the-shoulder, Mark Latham rubbish about classical music audiences. Any person with an open mind – and that certainly includes three-year-olds – can appreciate classical music. You only have to listen. The longer you listen, the better you will appreciate it. The same goes for any other sort of music.

Our modern lives are besieged by people trying to make us go shopping. In marketing, the aim is to make as much money as quickly and easily as possible. But part of the value of music (and the other arts) is that it offers an antidote to things that are quick and easy. It connects us to each other, and it also connects us to a vast pool of knowledge. This knowledge exists in musical form – in scores and recordings and in our memories. Bach and Beethoven and John Coltrane thought in music. African drummers think in music. Cajun fiddlers think in music. We can only understand them by thinking in music.

Putting music into words is hard, and ultimately impossible. It’s true we can speak technically; we can say, “That’s a diminished chord.” But this is just labelling. To understand the significance and the power of music in our lives and in our world – to appreciate music – we must sing it and play it and compose more of it. We must add to the pool.

So what do I want for my daughter? Well, I want her to be able to sing in tune and with confidence. I want her to have a good ear. It’s never too soon to start with this. I once asked a friend with a far better ear than mine how she acquired it. She told me her dad used to play games with her that involved identifying intervals and chords. She’d have been my daughter’s age, maybe slightly older. She loved the games and so she learnt.

I also want my daughter to read music, because it opens a vast library of literature – some of the greatest musical thought of Western civilisation. One does run up against people who disapprove of teaching musical literacy. They always turn out to be people who themselves do not read music. I have never heard of anyone who regretted having learnt.

I’d like my daughter to play an instrument should she want to. The ability to coax beautiful sounds from a box of wires or a tube with holes in it is one of the most magical things anyone can learn to do. Whether it’s a piano or a banjo, you have a direct connection to other musical minds – some of them great minds. You are placing your fingers exactly where Chopin – or Earl Scruggs – placed theirs.

Finally, I want my daughter to have the ability to create music that wasn’t there before, whether notated or through improvisation. Ideally both. And I want her to have curiosity about all sorts of music, and the patience to appreciate it. She will, of course, need curiosity and patience in the first place, but the deeper she goes into music, the more curiosity and patience she will learn.

Now my daughter stands a fair chance of achieving some of these things because her parents are musicians. She hears her mother sing and play the piano; she sees me hunched over manuscript paper. Something is likely to rub off. But I’d like all children to have these opportunities. Because most of all, I’d like Elsie to grow up in a world that values musical thought as much as other types of thought.

(Notice how there was nothing here about music making you better at languages or maths? It does that too.) •

Composer Andrew Ford presents The Music Show at 10 am and 10 pm each Saturday on ABC Radio National.

Wednesday, January 15, 2014

Book on terrorism launched: America’s war, method, target questionable: Sartaj Aziz

“The Thistle and the Drone: How America’s War on Terror Became a Global War on Tribal Islam,”


Director General ISSI Dr Rasul Bakhsh Rais


Islamabad—The Institute of Strategic Studies, Islamabad organized a launch of book, “The Thistle and the Drone: How America’s War on Terror Became a Global War on Tribal Islam,” and a public Talk Wednesday on “The Thistle and the Drone: Relations Between the Center and the Provinces” by Prof Akbar S. Ahmed Ibn Khaldun, Chair of Islamic Studies, American University, Washington DC & Nonresident Senior Fellow, Brookings Institution. Mr.Sartaj Aziz, Advisor to the Prime Minister on National Security and Foreign Affairs chaired.

The Director General ISSI Dr Rasul Bakhsh Rais in his welcome remarks said that Prof Akbar Ahmad is one of the few Pakistanis who have attained international recognition.

Prof Akbar S. Ahmed said the drone became a symbol of America’s war on terror. Its main targets appeared to be Muslim tribal groups belonging to Afghanistan, Pakistan, Yemen, Somalia, Kurds in Turkey and Tausug in the Philippines. Further, drones are also used by the US against the Paukhtun tribes of Afghanistan, by France in northern Mali against the Tuareg, and by Israel in Gaza. Prof Ahmed said that these communities - some of the most impoverished and isolated in the world, with identities that are centuries old had become the targets of the twenty-first centuries most advanced kill technology. He said that drone embodied the weaponry of globalisation: high tech in performance, sleek in appearance and global in reach. Professor Ahmad briefly talked about tribal societies. He focused on four major groups: the Pukhtun, Yemenis, Somalis and Kurds. According to Professor Ahmed, these communities lived by an ancient code of honor embodied in the behaviour of elders and over the centuries, orally transmitted from generation to generation. He briefly said that as the drone is an appropriate metaphor for the current age of globalisation, the thistle captures the essence of tribal societies. Prof Ahmed also discussed ‘Waziristan Model.” He also talked about three pillars essential for the stability of the culture: 1. tribal elders, 2. Mullah, and 3. Political agent.

According to him these three pillars are collapsing. He further said that several major developments took place in 2004: 1) President Musharraf weakened political administration, 2) Military invasion in tribal areas, 3) Drone strikes, 4) Emergence of militant groups in tribal areas. He also talked about cause and effect. In addition, he discussed the relation between center and periphery and the involvement of the United States that has fueled the war on terror. No one is immune to this violence—neither school children nor congregations in their houses of worship. Battered by military or drone strikes one day and suicide bombers the next, people on the periphery say, “Every day is like 9/11 for us.” He said that center needs to incorporate the periphery in mainstream.

Mr. Sartaj Aziz in his address said that the use of drones against tribal people is paradoxical. He said that in dissecting the conflict, the analogy of thistle and the drones is very revealing. He also talked about total ignorance about the values and realities of tribal societies. He said that each chapter of the book elaborates theme into its varying dimensions. He said that America is fighting the wrong war with wrong methods against the wrong people.

The chairman of the ISSI, Ambassador Khalid Mehmood, said that ethnicity and tribal identity is a crucial factor to terrorism. Also clash between center and periphery is significant to terrorism. He further said that Islam might be a contributory factor to extremism but not a driving force. He believes that the government needs to develop strong counter narrative to the people of the tribal area. He said it is important to understand the aspiration and grievances of the people of the tribal area. He said use of drones which are also inflicting havoc on innocent civilians is not merely a question of legality and constitutionally. It is above all a humanitarian question.

Uganda: National IDs can reduce passport forgeries













by Moses Walubiri

Uganda is not about to see the end of its passports ending up in the hands of foreigners – some of whom are lords of the underworld – unless, according to immigration boss, Godfrey Sasagah, “all Ugandans are issued with national IDS.”


The Director Citizenship and Immigration Control, Sasagah contends that the current layers of checks aimed at verifying the authenticity of information adduced by passport applicants is not watertight enough to preclude aliens from slipping through.

“We issue passports relying on recommendations of Local Councils (LCs). Many times, there are many loopholes because LCs officials are not thorough,” Sasagah told New Vision yesterday.

Uganda has not had functioning LCs for close to a decade following Rubaramira Ruranga’s successful petition to the Constitutional Court impugning the legal regime under which the LC elections were being conducted.

The then opposition figure convinced court that the 1997 Local Governments Act and 1993 National Youth and Women Council Act were passed under the Movement system and were no longer applicable in a multiparty dispensation.

With the Local Government Act yet to be amended to address the legal challenges that have thus far prevented conducting LC polls for two consecutive general elections, immigration has continued to rely on LC executives whose mandates expired ten years ago.

“National IDs will capture applicants’ bio data and ease our work,” Sasagah said, acknowledging that even when national IDs are issued out; it will only “significantly” reduce forgeries.

In a phone interview in which he addressed a host of issues pertaining to the spate of incidents in which foreigners with a criminal record are reported to be using Uganda’s travel documents, Sasagah noted that plugging the loopholes will require “a multipronged approach,” including rolling out e-passports.

An e-passport has a chip containing one’s bio data embedded in a passport, which precludes chances of forgeries, like people swapping passports.

Pertaining the spate of members of criminal rings – especially West African drug barons - in oriental countries accessing Uganda’s passports, Sasagah revealed that government has accepted to dispatch immigration officers to all its missions abroad, “beginning with those of special interest like China,” to “document Ugandans in those countries.”

The media has been awash with tales of suspected drugs traffickers and prostitution rings sullying Uganda’s image through using its passports in oriental countries.

A fact finding mission to China, India and other neighboring oriental countries by the Equal Opportunities Committee of parliament mid last year revealed that people trafficking Ugandan girls into prostitution are mainly West Africans using Ugandan passports.

Ugandans living in United Arab Emirates, through the Shadow Minister of Internal Affairs, Hussein Kyanjo, have long appealed to parliament to cause an inquiry into how criminals from West Africa are easily accessing Ugandan passports.

Uganda has three passport issuing centers outside the country – London, Pretoria and Washington – with government toying with the idea of opening another in Beijing or New Delhi to address what Sasagah labeled “increasing business interests in those countries.” 

Prof Abdi Ismail Samatar “Europe and USA are the biggest obstacles of Somalia to restore Peace and Law”



Prof Abdi Ismail Samatar


Head of African Research Association in North America Prof Abdi Ismail  samatar Said that USA and Europe are the biggest obstacles of Somalia to restore peace and power.

Talking to “Fil-Cumq” Al jazeera TV show last night Prof Abdi Ismail said that USA and Europe obstruct Arab Countries to Help Somalia re-establish peace and order with the plan of keeping the interest of their Somali Neighboring Kenya and Ethiopia allies.

He stated that Western countries have shown no visible support for Somalia to re-obtain the power and the respect it had in the region.

Abdi Ismail Samatar is Professor and Chair of Department of Geography,Environment and Society at the University of Minnesota and a Research fellow at the University of Pretoria.

Somali Pirates Seize Fewest Ships Since 2004 on Guards





By Natasha Doff

Somali pirates hijacked the fewest merchant ships since 2004 last year as armed guards and naval patrols helped deter and repel attacks on a trade lane linking Europe to Asia.

The number of vessels seized off the East African country’s coast fell to two last year from 14 in 2012, the International Maritime Bureau, a London-based group tracking sea crime, said in a report today. Last year’s tally was the smallest since 2004, data from the bureau show. The decrease helped to drive global piracy down to a six-year low.

Private armed guards, naval intervention and other on-board security measures combined with greater stability in Somalia to reduce attacks, according to the IMB. The cost of Somali piracy to the global economy was about $6 billion in 2012 and $7 billion the year before, according to Oceans Beyond Piracy, a project of the Broomfield, Colorado-based One Earth Future Foundation. The pirates had targeted ships that were sailing to or from Egypt’s Suez Canal, a waterway handling about 4.5 percent of oil trade.


Bloomberg News

Who Wins, Who Loses if the U.S. Starts Exporting Oil?




Photograph by Andrew Burton/Getty Images
Pumpjacks near Watford City, North Dakota



Somalia: Soma Oil & Gas Holdings Limited - Funding Agreement and Board Appointments





Soma Oil & Gas Holdings Limited ("Soma Oil & Gas" or "the Company") announces that it has secured an equity investment ofUS$50 million from a private investment company, Winter Sky. In conjunction with the funding agreement, three individuals connected to Winter Sky have joined the Soma Oil & Gas Holdings Limited board as Non Executive Directors.

This additional funding is sufficient to see the Company through the initial stages of the exploration programme and satisfy its obligations to the Government of the Federal Republic of Somalia under the Seismic Option Agreement.

Soma Oil & Gas is now in a position to finalise a contract with a seismic operator for the planned 2D exploration programme offshore Somalia and is in advanced negotiations. A further announcement will be made in due course.

In addition, the Company announces the appointment of Mohamad Ajami as a Non Executive Director. Mohamad has over 35 years of investing experience in the oil and gas, petrochemicals and mineral resources sectors and is a founder of the Levant Group, a firm focused on investments in oil & gas, mineral and recyclable energy mainly in Africa, Russia and the CIS. Mohamad was previously at Morrison Knudsen Corporation, a civil engineering and construction company (now part of URS Corporation).

Lord Howard, Chairman of Soma Oil & Gas, said:

"I welcome Winter Sky as a shareholder of Soma Oil & Gas and all of our new board members who I am sure will prove invaluable to the business."

Robert Sheppard, CEO of Soma Oil & Gas, said:

"Securing this funding agreement is a significant step forward for Soma Oil & Gas as it will enable us to finalise a contract for the seismic survey programme. We are in advanced negotiations with a contractor and expect to be able to make a further announcement in this regard shortly."

Moving into Mystery, Moving to Somaliland

"As soon as my feet hit the tarmac in Hargeisa, capitol of the north, the reality of our choice sank in." Rachel Pieh Jones said 



By

Today I’m writing at Babble about when we moved to Somaliland in 2003. I have to say this post was hard to write. Emotionally challenging, to dig back all these layers of years and try to remember what it was like in the very beginning.

The year I moved to Somaliland from the Midwest was the year a long and painful process of letting gobegan. I let go all-of-a-sudden, the immediate abandonment of everything comfortable and familiar within the space of a 30-hour airplane flight. I am still letting go, more of a slipping and grasping, as over the last eleven years the full impact of that initial release sinks deeper.

I knew letting go with this drastic of a move would require changing many surface things – the way I dressed and spoke and spent my holidays. But I didn’t realize how those surface things are rooted deep, connected to my sense of identity, the way I viewed people in the developing world, my values, even my sense of humor. I didn’t realize that letting go of what I knew, to embrace mystery would happen every single day and that it would change me to the core.

I write about what I think faith is for, about the wild and terrifying expatriate life we’ve been trying to live for eleven years now, about the things I lost and the things I learned.

In our first apartment, my husband and I were surrounded by Somali neighbors. We heard stories and rumors, met broken people and healing people. We both came from middle class families, had good educations and health, and carried a deep conviction that we had been blessed with much in order to give away much. A suburban life of white-picket fences and manicured lawns held little appeal.

Compelled to step outside our comfort zone, the more we heard about Somalia, the more our interest was piqued. What could be further from a midwestern, Christian upbringing than Somalia? Land of terrorists and suicide bombers, anarchy and AK-47s. Famine, poverty, female genital mutilation. People turned glassy-eyed and frowned when I told them where my husband and I were moving. When I was twenty-four. With two-year old twins. “Aren’t there, like, Muslims there?”
But, but, but, we weren’t moving to Somalia. We were moving to Somaliland. North of terrorists and suicide bombers and anarchy and famine. And we were moving with purpose. Through relationships formed in our Somali apartment building, my husband had been invited to teach English and Physics at the only functioning university. Here was an opportunity to give, to invest in the future leaders of a nation.

People often ask if I felt afraid, if the decision was a hard one to make. I struggle to answer because I don’t remember feeling afraid. I look back and see a 24-year old who felt invincible, who because of her faith was drawn to living a life of love and service, who wanted to see the world and not just the pretty, easy parts of it, who believed she had an obligation to give out the riches she had been given. I look back and see a young woman who didn’t know how hard it would be in the long-term.

I also believed we were giving ourselves and our children a gift. At two-years old they didn’t have a choice and were happy wherever mom and dad were. Though two can be a challenging age, it felt like a relatively simple age to move them overseas. Thoughts about their education hovered in the back of my mind but school seemed light years down the road. Like Scarlet O’Hara, I would think about it tomorrow.


People also often ask if we felt safe or if we thought about safety. I did think about safety but “safe” wasn’t a word I wanted to describe my life. A safe life felt too controlled, too predictable, too inward. Getting involved with people, being part of a developing nation, taking risks, and (hopefully) seeing those risks pay off in terms of development, character, and faith, were more important. And so we packed our bags.





After a season of brutal violence (which continued to plague the south) Somaliland was building from the ground up, the sere boulder-strewn and bullet-pocked ground up, to an uncertain future. The nation didn’t formally exist though money was printed, license plates formed, a national day celebrated, laws enacted, governments elected. There was even a constitution, two lines of which read: Somaliland has freedom of religion. Somalis are free to be Muslims. (So, yup, there would be Muslims there.)

As soon as my feet hit the tarmac in Hargeisa, capitol of the north, the reality of our choice sank in.
All at once, my flimsy headscarf slipped around on my curly blond hair and the twins started crying because they thought the swarming flies were bees and I realized I couldn’t carry them both plus the carry-ons plus keep my hair covered; My attempt at greeting the man at the visa desk (a make-shift counter set up exclusively for us) came out like a whispered croak and there really were guns everywhere and it hit me that I knew exactly three people in the entire country (married to one, practically still attached via umbilical cord to two). I felt stripped naked. No, past naked. Stripped to the bone, utterly vulnerable and exposed.

I was going to have to let go of everything I knew and learn a whole new way to live.

All thoughts of courage and choosing risk over safety and the value of building cross-cultural and cross-religious relationships now felt ridiculously foolish.

I hadn’t planned on turning weak-kneed at the airport. I had failed to grasp how profoundly this move to the Horn of Africa would put me on even footing with my toddlers. I had to relearn basic skills. Figure out how to dress myself in vast swaths of cloth. Learn to walk over uneven ground without rolling an ankle. Practice not oozing greasy spaghetti sauce down my front while eating with my right hand instead of a fork. Build relationships through dynamic gestures and miming. Don’t know the word for vomit? Act it out. Not sure how to say dog? Bark and crawl around on all fours. Except Somali dogs don’t bark, they waahwaah.


Everything felt like a mystery and I felt like a helpless alien. Somehow my desire to serve hadn’t included the desire to first be broken and stripped.

Now, eleven years after that arrival in Hargeisa, I know that brokenness and stripping are required for service. I know that without them, I would still be holding onto my own ideas about how to eat and dress and talk and live and love. Now I know that though it is humiliating to crawl around like a dog while trying to learn a new language, it also creates long-lasting bonds.

Now I know that releasing my ideas of development and leaning into a new culture’s values and ways of life, adapting when possible, and standing my ground (with grace) when I need to, are what make the expatriate experience not ridiculously foolish but wildly beautiful.

I think that’s what letting go is, what faith is for. Learning how to be comfortable with mystery and uncertainty, learning to live without having everything under control.

Embracing the wild and beautiful. Casting myself into the prickly cacti (okay, that was an accident) of a not-yet-for-real country and trusting I could make a difference. And, after getting over fear, intimidation, culture shock, trusting that this country could make a difference in me, too.

*Look for the follow-up post: When Letting Go is Right and Breaks Your Heart, an essay about emergency evacuations, health issues where there is no doctor, and choosing a boarding school.

Click here to read on the web: When Letting Go Means Leaning into Mystery

Princeton Lyman: Previous attempts to ‘bring Eritrea in from the cold’ have proved difficult, but we should still try





Princeton Lyman is a diplomat and former United States Ambassador to Nigeria and South Africa. The below is a response to Hank Cohen’s blog for African Arguments ‘Time to Bring Eritrea in from the Cold’
Ambassador Cohen is right that ending the conflict between Ethiopia and Eritrea is long overdue and would be of great benefit to both countries and the region. The same is true for better relations between Eritrea and the US. But Ambassador Cohen does not mention that the African Union was instrumental in calling for United Nations Security Council sanctions against Eritrea. Not a few Africa countries have been upset by perceived Eritrean actions either in Somalia or elsewhere in pursuing its conflict with Ethiopia. Eritrea has become somewhat of an outlier. And rapprochement has proved difficult.
In 2008, when I was at the Council on Foreign Relations I made a major effort to bring Eritrea and the US together. After months of discussion on how to do this, I suggested to the Eritrean ambassador the Council sponsor a meeting between Eritrean officials and a distinguished group of Americans no longer in government, but with strong backgrounds in the region, to discuss the whole range of issues between our two countries. The idea was that if the meeting were to go well, someone from the administration would join opening the way to more formal government-to-government meetings.
The Eritrean ambassador assured me his government had approved this proposal. I persuaded the outgoing Bush administration to hold off on a designation of Eritrea as a state sponsor of terrorism to give this meeting a chance. Though skeptical, the administration agreed. The list of Americans I had contacted and who had agreed to sit down with such a delegation for two days was impressive, including many former diplomats who had served in the region and others active in humanitarian program in Eritrea. What was still missing was the list of Eritrean participants. Shortly after the inauguration of President Obama, the Eritrean ambassador traveled home, promising me a list of Eritrean delegates when he returned. I did not hear back from him for months. When he finally contacted me, he told me that President Isaias had in fact killed the idea.
This is not to say that improvement in relations between the US and Eritrea does not remain desirable. Nor that any opening to settle the dispute between Eritrea and Ethiopia should not be seized. But it does reflect the reality that the government of Eritrea does not make it easy for such rapprochement. After all this time, and with so much suspicion and accusations, these processes cannot be solved by meetings that have strict preconditions, as Eritrea has often insisted upon, nor without a readiness to address the several issues at stake not just one. Perhaps another try at second track diplomacy might help to start the dialogue. I encourage Ambassador Cohen to pursue that and other ways to advance these worthy goals.

Chinese Dominance in Kenyan Digital Migration Raises Alarm




There are concerns that Chinese dominance of Kenya’s digital migration process could be used to muzzle freedom of the press. Courtesy: Miriam Gathigah

By Miriam Gathigah

NAIROBI, Jan 14 2014 (IPS) - Controversy and confusion have marked Kenya’s transition from analogue to digital television in keeping with the 2015 International Telecommunication Union deadline when all analogue signal transmission will cease. 
Digital migration, intended to give consumers of media content more choice and better service quality, has faced various hurdles in this East African nation and the government has already postponed the switch several times.
While the fate of a court case filed by three major media houses challenging the government’s decision to deny them a digital licence is yet to be decided, there are increasing concerns that the Chinese are occupying too much space in the local media platforms – particularly the Chinese dominance of the digital migration process.
Javas Bigambo, a political analyst with Interthoughts Consulting, a firm specialising in media, governance and policy, tells IPS it was no coincidence that a Chinese-owned company was given a digital licence and local media houses with significant infrastructure to transmit digitally were not. “We are still reeling from the controversial draconian Media Bill with heavy penalties for journalists and media houses, and now the government is auctioning media freedom to the highest bidder.”
Local TV broadcasters will be reduced to only producing content as Chinese-owned Pan-Africa Network Group’s (PANG) and SIGNET – a subsidiary of the national broadcaster – will serve as middlemen between local TV stations and consumers of media content. Both parties will provide all transmission at an agreed cost with the respective local media houses.
Alex Gakuru, the chair of ICT Consumers Association of Kenya and a member of the Digital Transition Committee multi-stakeholder task force established by the government, says that because China represses its domestic media there has developed in Kenya “the futuristic fear [that the Chinese will repress local media] ignore our constitution, laws and restructured judiciary.”
But Gakaru says such fears are misguided.
“The status of public communications is the legal and sole mandate of the Communications and Media Authority, rendering it illogical to conclude that all foreign companies ignore local laws opting to observe their home countries laws.”
Gakuru says that as the only digital signal distributors, “PANG and SIGNET are legally required to be neutral signal carriers – neither discriminating nor prioritising some broadcaster’s content over others, failure to which their licences risk revocation.”
But Gakuru tells IPS that one signal distributor would have been sufficient as a cost-saving measure as is the case with countries such as Australia.
“Two signal distributors were unnecessary and [financial and spectrally] resource wasteful in the first place. A third or further multiple distributors only aggravate the situation, if at all technically feasible.”
Grace Githaiga, an associate with Kenya ICT Action Network (KICTANet), tells IPS that although theCommunications Commission of Kenya (CCK), the independent regulatory authority for the communication industry in Kenya, argues that local media houses lost their bid to acquire a digital licence fairly, “local media houses have reason to be concerned over foreign control of the digital migration in the sense that we are mortgaging our rights.”
“CCK argues that it advised the local media companies to form a consortium and bid, which they did and lost. [But] there seems to be no affirmative action in supporting local entities,” she says.
But Gakuru says that the “fear the Chinese argument” is an exaggeration in this case since “mobile phone operators use Chinese technologies with millions of phones among other consumer electronics either manufactured or components assembled in China – including the iPhone, iPad and other Apple products.”
Government statistics show that China’s state news agency, Xinhua, provides news bulletins for 17 million Kenyan cell phones.
Concerns have also been raised over the fact that though the government ICT policy bars foreign companies from operating telecommunications infrastructure, that policy was suspended during the tendering process for the digital licence.
According to the government, the suspension was on condition that foreign companies commit to offload 20 percent of their shares to locals within three years of starting operations.
Gakuru says that the bone of contention between the government and local media houses is not media freedom but profit margins.
“The many new broadcasters will bite into the advertising spending previously enjoyed by a few. Advertising spending was 769 million dollars in 2011. Local TV stations previously enjoyed freedom to air whatever their profitability-friendly content they so desired.”
“We must recognise China as a superpower. Their dominance on Kenya’s digital migration landscape is a manifestation of their broader information and communications technologies ecology,” Gakuru says.
Gakuru adds that the current situation where media ownership has been the privilege of a few individuals to grant signal distribution to the same few is not an expression of media freedom.
According to Gakuru, challenging PANG as a signal distributor “would be an uphill task. They won an open and public tender bid and there is no need to insinuate favouritism, corruption or even that the media will be muzzled. Separate but associated StarTimes Media focuses on Set Top Boxes [which can be used to receive digital signals for analogue TV sets] and Pay TV business.”
Nonetheless, Githaiga cautions “there is need to understand the role of the signal carrier [in this case PANG and SIGNET].”
“Is the signal carrier for example allowed to edit content from any of the providers? Is it allowed to switch off a signal if content is considered harmful or even anti-government? This information needs to be made clear,” Githaiga says.